Home
Conservative views, news & action

Main Menu

  • The Front Page
  • News
  • Campaigns
  • Commentary
  • Forums
  • User Blogs
  • Shop
  • Bookstore
  • About Us

Comments

  • Coincidence?
    -
    Gary Gore
  • I am of the same opinion. An
    -
    Gary Gore
  • Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • Get Rid of the UN
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • league of democracies
    -
    kovach82
  • Let's remember this about Gallup...
    -
    Gary Gore
  • This section of the story is particularly remarkable...
    -
    Gary Gore
  • "McCain's not been a maverick on the war"
    -
    Gary Gore
  • Wall Street Reaction
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • I can hear Nancy Pelosi and Maxine Waters now...
    -
    Gary Gore
  • Much better alternative
    -
    Drew McKissick
  • Senate Bailout Bill
    -
    NM Jerry
  • Lord Save Us
    -
    NM Jerry
  • No Seconds for Hillary
    -
    NM Jerry
  • Well, now THERE's an
    -
    Drew McKissick

Active topics

  • Novak's knowledge of Clinton Campaign Dirt on Obama
  • Can we post truthful moderate posts here?
more

Buzzworthy

  • Popular
  • Emailed
  • Brownback backpedals on immigration bill
  • Hillary Clinton's take on American Idol
  • Daily Roundup
  • Racism and States Rights
  • Here comes the gun control crowd
  • Gender neutral bathrooms in Vermont
  • Not yours
  • A Timely Reminder of How our Tax System Works
  • Fourteen reasons to deport illegal aliens

Security

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

A Consensus on Immigration

Posted by : Drew McKissick September 15, 2006 - 12:00am
Filed under :
  • Immigration
  • Security

Congress is back in session and the battle over immigration reform has resumed.

 

For the past month or so, GOP House members have taken the issue on the road and held town hall meetings discussing the topic in congressional districts all across the country.  What has been confirmed by such meetings is that a true consensus of public opinion does exist on the immigration issue.  More specifically, that the majority of the American people want better enforcement of our borders and our current immigration laws.  Further, they are opposed to laws that reward illegal behavior.

 

Some pollsters and politicians have attempted to confuse the issue by combining various reform proposals in their presentations to the public.  They cleverly propose amnesty oriented versions of reform combined with nods toward better documentation and border enforcement.  And they make such combined proposals as though they are necessary in order to build a majority consensus on how to approach the issue.

 

What they neglect to point out however is that there already is a stand alone majority of public opinion on how to approach the immigration problem, and that it favors a border enforcement approach.  For example, the latest Fox News poll suggests that 77% of Americans think our border security is too lax, a healthy majority by any definition.

 

Further, when the additional aspects of the “comprehensive” proposals (which is code for providing amnesty to illegal aliens) are accurately described, the public is decidedly opposed.

 

When the public learns that the comprehensive approach would mean legalizing those who have come to this country illegally, they’re opposed.  When they learn if would mean pardoning those that have committed Social Security fraud, they’re opposed.  And when they learn that it would mean allowing illegal aliens to legally collect government benefits, they are opposed.

 

The proponents of comprehensive reform know that the only way they can enact amnesty related proposals is to piggy-back them along with a healthy dose of tough talk, or an enforcement related bill.  And the only thing standing in the way of the success of that strategy is the House Republican leadership.

 

Fortunately the Founding Fathers saw fit to have at least one chamber of our legislative branch elected in its entirety every two years, ensuring that members would constantly be exposed to public sentiment and hopefully be more inclined to represent it, given that they would likely wish to keep their jobs.

 

This fact is not lost on a House leadership that would like to remain in leadership.  And they are keenly aware of what the White House and some in the Senate seem to have missed (or just ignore) – that the party’s core constituency is opposed to anything that resembles amnesty.

 

At a recent GOP leadership meeting reporting on the results of their immigration field hearings, Republican Homeland Security Committee Chairman Peter King stated, “I have never seen such a disconnect between the American people and the elite”.  Michigan Republican Peter Hoekstra highlighted the issue’s national security implications, saying “There is a simple reason why we need border security.  We are a nation at war.  We face a dangerous enemy that is intent on attacking us again.”  Exactly.

 

The House Republicans have resolved to propose and pass several border and immigration law enforcement measures in the coming weeks, attempting the put the Democrats on the political defensive as well as on the wrong side of public opinion just prior to the November elections.  At this point, it seems each of the bills will focus on a single aspect of the immigration problem in order to focus attention, create more recorded votes and prevent opponents (or amnesty supporters) from watering things down with a comprehensive bill.

 

The fact is that illegal immigration is out of control, and the number of aliens entering the country has been increasing every year.  They’re beginning to show up in large numbers in states and rural areas where people didn’t expect them, and where the infrastructure is unable to accommodate them.  Education, law enforcement and health care systems are heavily effected, and the result is a great burden on taxpayers.

 

Then there is also the issue of the fairness of proposals which would grant amnesty to those who have broken our laws.  Not to mention the fact that such a proposal was tried before in 1986 and helped create the illegal immigration problems we have today.  To make it worse for conservatives, it’s being supported by a Republican President and Republican Senators.

 

The result is the crystallization of a major political issue that the majority of Americans are beginning to see as relevant to their everyday lives.

 

For an issue to “cut it” in politics, it must be salient and relevant to large numbers of people.  This issue has that in spades, and then some.  And the House Republicans understand.

  • Login or register to post comments
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Technorati

Most Popular

  • Brownback backpedals on immigration bill
  • Hillary Clinton's take on American Idol
  • Daily Roundup
  • Racism and States Rights
  • Here comes the gun control crowd

Most Emailed

  • Gender neutral bathrooms in Vermont
  • Not yours
  • A Timely Reminder of How our Tax System Works
  • Fourteen reasons to deport illegal aliens

Get Connected

Get daily Outpost updates:

Subscribe in a reader

Add to Technorati Favorites

User login

Login/Register

Good Stuff

  • Hot Stuff
  • Editor's Picks
  • Tightening polls?
    -
    Drew McKissick
    2
  • The Obama Debate Every American Should See
    -
    Gary Gore
    1
  • Historic Losses Despite Late Rally
    -
    Gary Gore
    1
  • Tonight's Presidential Debate is in McCain's Favorite Style
    -
    Gary Gore
    0
  • RNC: Obama-associated Organization, ACORN, Undermining Electoral System
    -
    Gary Gore
    0
  • Liberal housing policy chickens coming home to roost
    -
    Drew McKissick
  • Fight With Me, Fight!
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • Obama Once Again Playing the Race Card
    -
    Gary Gore
  • President Bush Takes Action on Two Major Issues
    -
    Gary Gore
  • Questions for Senator Obama
    -
    Steve McCullough
more

Commentary

  • Liberal housing policy chickens coming home to roost
  • Batten down the hatches Sarah!
  • Obama tries to woo evangelicals
more

User Blogs

  • Vetted to be Commander-in-Chief?
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • Economics and Politics
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • What Part Of "Shall Not Be Infringed" Don't You Understand, Senator?
    -
    FMeekins
  • Fight With Me, Fight!
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • Into The Heart Of Darkness, Part 1
    -
    FMeekins
  • Into The Heart Of Darkness, Part 1
    -
    FMeekins
  • World's Gutter Governments To Sit In Judgment Over U.S. Human Rights Record
    -
    FMeekins
  • The Truth - According to the "Mainstream Media"
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • Meet the Female VP Candidate
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • National Zoo Exhibits Ethnic Favortism
    -
    FMeekins
  • Phelps' Cult Veers Into Further Irrationality
    -
    FMeekins
  • China Agitates To Undermine American Liberties
    -
    FMeekins
  • Religion of Peace
    -
    Steve McCullough
  • When White Apathy Trumps Unrealistic Black Expectations
    -
    justifiableacce...
  • Hey America... Don't Fear Depression, Fear Assimulation
    -
    justifiableacce...
more

Resources

Columnists
  • Andrew Anthony
  • Ann Coulter
  • Charles Krauthammer
  • George Will
  • Hugh Hewitt
  • John Hawkins
  • John Stossel
  • Jules Crittenden
  • Larry Elder
  • Larry Kudlow
  • Lorie Byrd
  • Mark Steyn
  • Mary Katherine Ham
  • Melanie Phillips
  • Michael Barone
  • Michelle Malkin
  • Mickey Kaus
  • Mike Adams
  • Monsoor Ijaz
  • Peggy Noonan
  • Tammy Bruce
  • Thomas Joscelyn
  • Thomas Sowell
  • W. Thomas Smith, Jr.
Conservative Causes
  • American Conservative Union
  • American Spectator
  • American Thinker
  • Cato Institute
  • Citizens Against Government Waste
  • City Journal
  • Club for Growth
  • Conservative Voice
  • Earmark Watch
  • Eye on the UN
  • FIRE
  • Frontpage Magazine
  • Global Warming Skeptics
  • GOP USA
  • Heritage Foundation
  • Human Events
  • Independent Women's Forum
  • Move America Forward
  • National Journal
  • National Review
  • Newsmax
  • Opinion Journal
  • Pajamas Media
  • Patriot Post
  • Politico.com
  • Porkbusters
  • Real Clear Politics
  • Reason
  • Sunlight Foundation
  • Tech Central Station
  • Townhall
  • Weekly Standard
Outpost Links
  • Ace of Spades
  • Blogs for Bush
  • Captain's Quarters
  • Hot Air
  • Instapundit
  • Michelle Malkin
  • Newsbusters
  • Outside the Beltway
  • Patrick Ruffini
  • Polipundit
  • Qube TV
  • Wizbang
National Blogs
  • A Blog for All
  • Alarming News
  • A Little More to the Right
  • Alpha Patriot
  • Ambra Nykol
  • American Mind
  • Amy Proctor
  • Ankle Biting Pundits
  • Ann Althouse
  • A Second-Hand Conjecture
  • Atlas Shrugs
  • Betsy Newmark
  • Big Lizards
  • Bizzy Blog
  • Blogs for Victory
  • Blue Crab Boulevard
  • Brainster's Blog
  • California Conservative
  • California Yankee
  • Captain's Quarters
  • Carol Platt Liebau
  • Charmaine Yoest
  • Classical Values
  • Coldhearted Truth
  • Confederate Yankee
  • Confirm Them
  • Conservatism with Heart
  • Conservative Revolution
  • Conservative Thinking
  • Counseling Kevin
  • Counterterrorism Blog
  • Culture Wire
  • D.C. Thornton
  • Daily Gut
  • David Limbaugh
  • Dean's World
  • Decision '08
  • Democracy Project
  • Don Surber
  • Durham in Wonderland
  • Ed Driscoll
  • Elephants in the Bluegrass
  • Evangelical Outpost
  • Ex-Liberal in Hollywood
  • Extreme Mortman
  • Fausta's Blog
  • Flopping Aces
  • Four Right Wing Wackos
  • Gateway Pundit
  • Gay Patriot
  • GOP Bloggers
  • Hang Right Politics
  • Hot Air
  • House of Eratosthenes
  • Hugh Hewitt
  • Ian Schwartz
  • INDC Journal
  • Indep. Women's Forum Blog
  • Instapundit
  • Irish Spy
  • J's Cafe Nette
  • James Lileks' Buzz Blog
  • James Lileks' The Bleat
  • Jammie Wearing Fool
  • Jihad Watch
  • Jim Treacher
  • John Stossel
  • Joust The Facts
  • Jules Crittenden's Forward Movement
  • Junkyard Blog
  • Just One Minute
  • Kim Priestap
  • Kobayashi Maru
  • Larry Kudlow
  • LaShawn Barber
  • Leibowitz's Canticle
  • Let Freedom Ring
  • Little Green Footballs
  • Lorie Byrd
  • Mary Katherine Ham
  • Media Lies
  • Michael Barone
  • Michelle Malkin
  • Ms. Underestimated
  • My Vast Right Wing Conspiracy
  • Neo-con News
  • Neo-Neocon
  • Outside the Beltway
  • Outwit, Outblog, Outsnark
  • Patrick O'Hannigan
  • Patterico's Pontifications
  • Pirate's Cove
  • Polipundit
  • Powerline Blog
  • Pro-Life Blogs
  • Protein Wisdom
  • Publius Rendezvous
  • Pundit Review
  • Q and O Blog
  • Relapsed Catholic
  • Rhymes with Right
  • Riehl World View
  • Right Coast
  • Right Voices
  • Right Wing News
  • RightWing Nuthouse
  • Robert Bluey
  • Roger L. Simon
  • Say Anything
  • Sigmund, Carl and Alfred
  • Sissy Willis
  • Six Meat Buffet
  • Slobakan's Site O' Schtuff
  • SoCal Pundit
  • Stones Cry Out
  • Stop the ACLU
  • Strata-Sphere
  • Suitably Flip
  • Sundries Shack
  • Sweetness & Light
  • Texas Rainmaker
  • The Anchoress
  • The Dawn Patrol
  • The Moderate Voice
  • Thomas Sowell
  • Tigerhawk
  • Unalienable Right
  • Uncooperative Blogger
  • UNCoRRELATED
  • Urban Infidel
  • Verum Serum
  • Veteran American Voices
  • Viking Pundit
  • Vodkapundit
  • Volokh Conspiracy
  • Wake Up America
  • Warner Todd Huston
  • Watcher of Weasels
  • Wendy Shalit
  • WILLisms
  • Winds of Change
  • Wizbang
  • XDA
  • XRLQ

Tags

2008 abortion Amnesty Bailout Barack Obama Congress Democrats Economy Fred Thompson Gay Marriage George Bush Hillary Clinton Immigration Joe Biden John McCain Judiciary Media Mike Huckabee Mitt Romney Obama Politics Republicans Rudy Giuliani Sarah Palin Supreme Court
more tags

Powered by FeedBurner

Conservative Outpost is a project of Outpost Communications - Copyright 2008 - All Rights Reserved